Preventative Medication for Malaria in Dominican Republic

QUESTION

I just read the CDC recommended medicines for preventing malaria and I am confused. It gives the pros and cons for taking one drug over another. My husband and I are in excellent health, we need our td boosters. Our 15 year old is current in his vaccinations. We will be in D.R. for 2.5 weeks near Jarabacoa then Rio San Juan. We will be on a missionary trip. What medicine should be take in your opinion before hand?

ANSWER

Apart from some basic differences, particularly regarding which forms of malaria they are effective and against, and in what areas of the world, the choice of which anti-malarial to take mostly comes down to personal preferences. So, for example, in most of Africa, malaria is resistant to chloroquine, so this drug is not recommended for travellers; conversely, in parts of Thailand, malaria is resistant to mefloquine, so likewise, if travelling to those areas, you would need to pick another drug.

Having said that, in the Dominican Republic the malaria is sensitive to all forms of anti-malarial drugs, so you don’t have to worry about that. Between the four main types of drug you can take (atovaquone-proguanil, doxycycline, mefloquine and chloroquine), there are significant differences in price, frequency and duration of taking the tablets and side effects, all of which may influence your decision to take one over another. They are all roughly equal in terms of their efficacy in preventing malaria, apart from when resistance is an issue, as I’ve mentioned.

Of the four, chloroquine and mefloquine are taken weekly, while atovaquone-proguanil (often sold as Malarone) and doxycycline are taken daily. Some people prefer the convenience of only having to take a pill every week, but the disadvantage is that these both have to be started 2 weeks before you travel, whereas the daily medications can be started the day before you leave. While Malarone only needs to be taken for one week after returning from your trip, the others should be taken for a full four weeks, to ensure that malaria does not surface once you’re back.

All have some reported side effects, but in my experience, Malarone has the fewest and the most mild, though some people report upset stomachs and disturbed sleep. Chloroquine also has some potential gastrointestinal side effects and can also produce itching, which is a particularly common side effect in people of African descent. The tablets have a metallic taste which some people find unpleasant.

Doxycycline is also an antibiotic, which means it can also help prevent other infections while travelling, though one of its common side effects is sun sensitivity, which may make it less suitable for travelling in tropical areas (personally I have not experienced this side effect, though I have known many people who have).

Mefloquine (sold as Lariam) is not recommended for people with a history of mental illness, and is known to have psychiatric side effects, including nightmares, hallucinations and even altered behavior (again, my whole family took Lariam during one trip, and no one experienced any such side effects, but you should be aware of the possibilities).

Another important factor to consider is price: doxycycline is usually the cheapest drug, and Malarone the most expensive (could be as much as $100 for each of you, for enough to cover the 2.5 week trip, plus a week of tablets once you get back), with the others somewhere in between.

Again, ultimately the choice usually comes down to what factors are important to you and your personal preference. I tend to pay the extra for Malarone since I prefer the convenience of starting the pills right before I leave, and only taking them for a week when I return. Furthermore, when I am away, I am usually working outside, and so would rather not risk the potential sun sensitivity side effect of doxycycline. You should also talk with your doctor about what is usually available in your area from local pharmacies, as they may not carry the full selection of choices.

Malaria Pills Vietnam

QUESTION

I am travelling from Hanoi to Ho Chi Minh city via Haalong Bay, Hue and Hoi An, all are Costal areas. Should I take Malarone? I would prefer not to as I am trying to get pregnant.

ANSWER

In Vietnam, costal areas north of Nha Trang are considered malaria-free, as are the cities of Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh city. As such, it is only rural and costal areas closer to Ho Chi Minh city where you might be at risk. One option you have is to take mefloquine (Lariam) – it is safe to take while pregnant (or trying to get pregnant), and is effective in most areas of Vietnam. There is resistance to mefloquine in the Mekong Delta region, but it doesn’t sound like you will be travelling there, so this shouldn’t be a problem.

Malaria Fever and Recovery

QUESTION

My 21 year old daughter spent 4 months on a study abroad program in Dakar. A week before returning home she started having night fevers and would complain of retrosternal pain and rib and neck and shoulder pain. The next day she would be fine.

The episodes came every other day and eventually it occurred to her that it might be malaria. It was evening so she went to a pharmacy for a rapid diagnostic test which they didn’t have but they felt she had malaria based on her symptoms and gave her a 3 day course of artesunate-mefloquine.

She returned to the United States and a day after taking her last dose, she was seen by a physician and tests were done which showed that she had contracted Plasmodium falciparum malaria. Other than the smears, all her lab tests and CXR were normal and there were no abnormal findings on physical exam, in fact she was the picture of health.

We were told that she was cured and that no follow up was necessary and that she could continue with her planned trip to Thailand the next day. About 6 hours before boarding the plane to Bangkok she developed fever of 100.9 but had absolutely no other symptoms or pain. About an hour later she had a bout of diarrhea. She had one more low grade fever on the flight (99.8). I spoke to another physician who seems more familiar with malaria and was told that she is not actually cured and may continue to have episodic fevers and symptoms for a while or it’s possible she was just suffering from an ordinary garden variety gastrointestinal bug.

I have many questions. I understand that her malaria is the most virulent type. How is it that all her lab work and physical exam is normal 1 day after completing treatment? Can we expect it to remain normal? What causes the episodic fevers if she is supposedly cured? She is on doxycycline again prophylactically (which she was on in Senegal) while in Thailand. Should she be on something else since she did contract malaria on doxycycline? (She took it religiously). Thanks for any advice. She will be seeing a physician in Bangkok ASAP, but since I won’t be there to ask questions, I am hoping you can give me some answers. Your site is the best information I have found on malaria.

ANSWER

Many thanks for the comprehensive information you have provided regarding your daughter’s condition. Even though your daughter did have the most virulent form of malaria, she was very smart to seek treatment relatively promptly, and lucky to receive appropriate medication (artemisinin-based combination therapies, such as artesunate-mefloquine, are recommended by the World Health Organization as first-line treatment against malaria). It is likely due to this prompt and effective action that her lab tests and blood parameters were all normal so soon after treatment; had she waited longer for treatment, the consequences could have been much more severe. No resistance to this medication has been detected in Africa as of yet, so she should be fully cured and thus her health should remain stable; a blood smear, where her blood is examined under a microscope, can determine this; this is a very standard procedure so could easily be carried out in Thailand if she wants.

Fever is a side effect of the body’s immune system responding to a disease threat, so it is not uncommon for some symptoms to carry on after treatment. In addition, mild side effects of anti-malarial medication can often mimic the symptoms of malaria itself, including fever and nausea.

Given also the (entirely reasonable) possibility of an additional, unrelated stomach bug, I suspect that your daughter has successfully beaten off this malaria attack, and while she should remain vigilant if similar symptoms arise again, her health in the future should not be adversely affected at all by this episode.

Also, as mentioned briefly above, medical professionals in Thailand should be well equipped to diagnose and treat malaria if she suspects she has been reinfected. It is worth noting that malaria in south-east Asia has shown signs of resistance to mefloquine (as well as other drugs, such as chloroquine and sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine), so if she does require treatment while there, she should make sure the medication they provide does not contain any of the afore-mentioned compounds.

Regarding doxycycline, it’s great that your daughter took it religiously—that is certainly the first step towards protection. Randomized placebo controlled trials have shown it is between 92-96% effective in preventing P. falciparum malaria, which is very good, but obviously not 100% perfect – even when taken perfectly, some infections do occur. In addition, there is some data which suggests that dairy products, taken together with doxycycline, may limit  the uptake of the drug. This is rarely communicated to patients, who are instead contrarily told sometimes that taking the pills together with dairy products can reduce side effects! As such, please let your daughter know that she should avoid dairy products for 2-3 hours around the time she takes her doxycycline.

Malaria Treatment with Fansidar

QUESTION

My husband has Malaria following a trip to Kenya and has had a fever for three days. We are in Russia and the only drug available at the pharmacy was Fansidar (we also have some Doxcycyclin). He took three Fansidar tablets last night and feels better but the fever has still not completely gone. What should we do? Take more Fansidar? Thanks for your help.

ANSWER

A single dose of three tablets is the correct amount for an adult over 45kg in weight—do not take any more. Unfortunately, Fansidar is not recommended as the first-line drug against malaria any more since many strains of P. falciparum (the most dangerous type of malaria, and the most common type in Kenya) now have resistance to Fansidar. This could be one reason why the treatment is not fully successful, though it could also be that the treatment has worked, but it will take a day or two more before your husband fully recovers.

Make sure your husband takes in plenty of fluids, and anti-inflammatory drugs such as ibuprofen might help with the fever and any aches he could also be suffering from.

If your husband is still feeling sick after a few days, you should try to have another blood test to see if the malaria parasites are still present in his blood. If you, you should try to find an artemisinin-based combination therapy, such as Coartem, Duo-Cotecxin or Alu. These are the most effective medications against malaria that are currently available, and are recommended as first-line treatment by the World Health Organization (for uncomplicated malaria).

New Treatment for Malaria

QUESTION

New treatment for malaria?

ANSWER

The most recently developed type of treatment for malaria actually has very ancient origins. The herb wormwood (Artemisia annua) has been used in ancient Chinese medicine for hundreds, even thousands, of years to cure certain fevers.

In the 1970s, a Chinese research program intensively sought new medications against malaria, as part of their Vietnam war effort. They re-discovered wormwood, and from it isolated the compound artemisinin, which is highly effective against malaria parasites in the blood, and kills them very quickly. Due to its quick action against malaria, there was concern that use of artemisinin alone would lead to resistance developing rapidly in the malaria parasite, as was seen with chloroquine in many parts of the world. As such, the World Health Organisation recommended that artemisinin should only be used in combination with another anti-malarial drug with a longer lasting action, to prevent resistance.

A number of such compounds, containing artemisinin derivatives and a second anti-malarial, have now been developed. These are collectively called “artemisinin-based combination therapies,” or ACTs. Some of the main artemisinin compounds used in these drugs are artemether, artesunate and dihydroartemisinin, and the brand names of the drugs as they are marketed (in combination with other compounds, such as lumefantrine, piperaquine and pyronaridine) include Coartem, Pyramax and Duo-Cotecxin.

Coartem Treatment

QUESTION

my husband has been taking coartem for 3 days now. He was fine yesterday and then last night the symptoms re-appeared like it was day one. Can I carry on with coartem and start another course? Or shall I switch to something else ? If so, what? We live in zambia by the way.

Thank you for your help.

ANSWER

If your husband still has strong symptoms after taking all doses of the Coartem, go back to see your doctor  or to the clinic for another blood test. If it is positive, then your doctor may recommend trying a different form of anti-malarial medication—artemisinin-based combination therapy (a group of medications that includes Coartem) is recommended as the first-line treatment against malaria, but a second line option could be atovaquone-proguanil (Malarone) or another medication. Please note that Fansidar (sulfadoxine and pyrimethamine) and chloroquine are not recommended for use in Africa as levels of resistance are high. 

It could be that the medication hasn’t had time to fully act, which is why it is important to wait until the full dose has been taken, and then to confirm that malaria is still present. Sometimes the side effects of anti-malarials can appear similar to malaria itself, such as nausea, chills, body aches, etc, so it is important not to start another course of treatment without further diagnosis.

We are actually very interested in learning about our readers’ experiences with anti-malarial medications, and so we would be very grateful if you might be able to take a few minutes to complete our malaria survey we are running on Malaria.com. We will post any findings that may be of interest to our readership on Malaria.com later this year—all submissions are completely anonymous. Many thanks for your time and help, and I hope your husband recovers fully soon.

Treatment and Management of Malaria Parasite

QUESTION

What are the treatments and management of malaria?

ANSWER

Treatment is actually part of the strategy for managing malaria, so I will come back to that later. The other main ways in which malaria is controlled is through prevention, diagnosis (followed by treatment if necessary) and education.

1) Prevention:

There are a number of ways to prevent malaria. These can be placed into two categories: medication and vector protection.

For medication, there are drugs you can take to prevent the malaria parasite from developing after someone is bitten by an infected mosquito. These drugs are known as “chemoprophylaxis.”

There are several different kinds, such as doxycycline, mefloquine (marketed as Lariam), atovaquone-proguanil (marketed as Malarone) and chloroquine—the type you use depends on the type of malaria present in the area. For example, in much of Africa and India, malaria is resistant to chloroquine, so this cannot be used as a prophylactic. In parts of Thailand, resistance to mefloquine has emerged. However, if the appropriate type of prophylaxis is used, it is very effective against malaria.

The problem is that these drugs have not been tested for long-term use, can be expensive and may have side-effects. Therefore they are of limited use for people who live in areas where malaria is endemic, and are more appropriate for travelers who are in malarial areas for short amounts of time. However, anti-malarial medication may be used in a very specific way for people at particularly high-risk for malaria, such as pregnant women and young children. In these cases, the high-risk individuals receive a dose or series of doses of malaria medication in order to prevent malaria. This form of prevention is known as intermittent preventive therapy (IPT).

Vector prevention involves protecting oneself against getting bitten by mosquitoes. This can involve wearing long-sleeved clothing in the evenings and at night, when malaria mosquitoes are most active, or wearing insect repellent on exposed skin. Indoor residual spraying, whereby repellent and insecticides are sprayed inside the house, can also be used to bring down the number of mosquitoes.

Another very effective technique for preventing malaria is to sleep under a long-lasting insecticide-treated bednet. The mesh acts as a barrier against the mosquitoes, and the insecticide impregnated in the mesh further repels the mosquitoes and prevents them from biting through the mesh.

2) Diagnosis

Diagnosis is considered a crucial step in controlling malaria, since it ensures that people are receiving correct medication, whether for malaria or for another condition which is causing their symptoms. Currently, the most commonly observed form of diagnosis is through microscopy of thick and thin blood films, which can be stained if necessary. These should be read by a qualified technician to determine both the species of malaria infection and the intensity of parasitaemia (number of parasites in the blood).

More recently, other methods for diagnosis have emerged. These include the use of rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) which utilize a drop of blood applied to a reagent strip which very quickly reacts to show whether the patient is infected with malaria. While considered generally more sensitive than blood films, some RDTs don’t test for all types of malaria parasite, and many require that the reagents be kept cold in order for the test to be effective, which can be a problem in some developing countries.

Perhaps the most sensitive test for malaria is through PCR, which can theoretically detect a single malaria parasite in a drop of blood, and also determine the species. However, measures of infection intensity require an alternative form of PCR, called real-time PCR, which can be technologically challenging. All forms of PCR require a lot of expensive equipment and reagents, trained technicians and take several hours to run.

3) Treatment

Malaria treatment can be determined based on the diagnostic results, as well as other factors, such as:

  • The area where the infection was acquired and its drug-resistance status
  • The clinical status of the patient
  • Any accompanying illness or condition
  • Pregnancy
  • Drug allergies, or other medications taken by the patient

Most uncomplicated (i.e. not severe) cases of P. falciparum can be treated with oral medication, such as artemisinin-based combination therapies (ACTs). Artemisinin is given in combination with another anti-malarial drug in order to prevent resistance from developing in the parasite. Patients who have complicated (severe) P. falciparum malaria or who cannot take oral medications should be given the treatment by continuous intravenous infusion, with quinine recommended by WHO as the first-line treatment.

Other drugs, which are used in some settings, are considered second-line or alternative forms of treatment. These include:

  • chloroquine (very rarely used for P. falciparum, due to widespread resistance)
  • atovaquone-proguanil (Malarone®)
  • mefloquine (Lariam®)
  • quinine
  • quinidine
  • doxycycline (used in combination with quinine)
  • clindamycin (used in combination with quinine)

In addition, primaquine is active against the dormant parasite liver forms (hypnozoites) and prevents relapses, for patients with P. vivax or P. ovale malaria. Primaquine should not be taken by pregnant women or by people who are deficient in G6PD (glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase). Patients should not take primaquine until a screening test has excluded G6PD deficiency.

4) Education

Through education, people living in at-risk areas for malaria transmission can learn about ways to prevent the disease (see above), as well as what to do if they suspect they are infected (i.e. seek diagnosis). Similarly, education is important for travellers visiting malarial areas, so they know the best ways in which to avoid being infected.

ACT Therapy, Missed Doses

QUESTION

I had recently encountered with malaria and started artemether and lumefantrine . Out of 6 tab of 80mg 4  I had taken 2 missed. Please suggest.

ANSWER

When a dose of ACT is missed, do not take an extra dose to compensate. Instead, take the next dose as soon as you remember, and continue until you have taken all of the tablets. Keep a close watch on any symptoms of illness that might suggest recrudescence (which occurs when all the parasites in the blood have not been killed, and so can begin to multiply again after treatment finishes).

If you suspect recrudescence, go back to your doctor for another diagnosis, and another dose of ACT. Please comply to the treatment and do not miss doses! This can lead to resistance against the drugs developing in the malaria parasites.