Malaria or Kidney Infection?

by

QUESTION

Two months ago my daughter was in Uganda working and when came back to the States she was hospitalized for 4 days with Malaria symptoms. Her tests came back negative they really didn’t act like they knew how to treat this. They kept telling her they didn’t know how to diagnosis Malaria. So they treated her for it. She now after 2 months is once again hospitalized with the same symptoms. They are telling her they think it is a kidney infection. Can malaria be misdiagnosed as a kidney infection. She once again has all the symptoms as malaria?

ANSWER

What tests did the doctors do to try to diagnose malaria in your daughter when she first got back to the States? Usually, malaria is diagnosed by a blood test, whereby a trained technician will look at the patient’s blood under a microscope. The technician looks for signs of the malaria parasite in the patient’s blood, and if seen, can determine the intensity of the infection as well as the species of malaria. This is important information for accurate treatment. Alternatively, rapid diagnostic tests, which utilize a droplet of blood in a device which looks similar to a pregnancy test, and can very quickly determine whether someone is infected with malaria. It is important to know that malaria cannot be diagnosed by looking at standard blood parameters. If you don’t think your doctors know what is afflicting your daughter, you should take her to a clinic which specializes in tropical or travel medicine. There, they will certainly know how to effectively diagnose your daughter.

Given that your daughter experienced a resurgence of symptoms two months after returning, if she did have malaria, then there are two kinds which she might have: Plasmodium ovale and Plasmodium vivax. The other types of malaria, including the most deadly kind, P. falciparum, are not able to come back and relapse once they are treated. However, in order to prevent future relapses, your daughter may also have to be treated with another form of medication called primaquine. I will emphasize again, however, that it is crucial to gain an accurate diagnosis before taking any form of treatment for malaria.

Effects of Malaria

by

QUESTION

what are effects of malaria?

ANSWER

If a person becomes infected with malaria, they may start to experience the symptoms of the disease. These include high fever, aches, chills, nausea, headache, and sometimes more severe manifestations, such as severe anemia, impaired consciousness and even coma or death. These latter severe effects are more commonly associated with Plasmodium falciparum infection, the most deadly form of malaria.

Malaria: Should I See a Doctor?

by

QUESTION

For the last couple of days I am suffering from all the symptoms that are mentioned on your website and I am taking tylenol for these symptoms thinking that it is flu but I am feeling better now. Should I still see a doctor or keep taking Tylenol?

ANSWER

Symptoms of malaria often include high fever, aches, chills, nausea, and headache.  When severe, malaria can lead to anemia, impaired consciousness and even coma or death.  The best course of action is to get a simple blood test to check if you have malaria, because if you do have it,  early treatment with the appropriate drug (for the type of malaria you have), is essential.

You should also know how to prevent getting malaria. The first thing to do is to make sure you are protecting yourself sufficiently from mosquito bites. You can’t get malaria if you aren’t bitten by mosquitoes, and the type of mosquitoes that transmit malaria usually bite at night. As such, it is crucial to sleep every night under a long-lasting insecticide treated bednet. If you have one, it might need to be re-dipped in insecticide to make sure it keeps working effectively. Also, you should make sure all your windows and doors are properly screened to prevent mosquitoes from coming in; many people also do something called “indoor residual spraying” where they spray insecticide on the walls inside their house to kill any mosquitoes which might come in. If you live in an urban area, this might not be necessary if you can get good screens, or indeed if you have air conditioning (mosquitoes do not like cooler environments). Finally, you should try to wear long-sleeved clothing in the evenings and at night, again to stop mosquitoes from biting.

Recurrence of Malaria Symptoms

by

QUESTION

If a person suffering from malaria is given the proper treatment and he gets well but he again develops the symptoms of malaria..? These symptoms would arise from liver or blood? Who’ll be responsible for the recurrence of the symptoms?

ANSWER

Malaria can come back in three ways: first of all, the person could have been successfully treated, but then re-infected again by being bitten by an infected mosquito. In these cases, the person should focus on improved malaria prevention, such as sleeping under a long-lasting insecticide treated bednet.

Secondly, the patient could have recrudescence: when the patient takes medication, the treatment kills most of the malaria parasites in the blood, and enough so the patient feels better again, but some parasites still remain. Then, after the treatment finished, the parasite is able to replicate again, they increase in number in the blood and the patient feels ill again. In this case, you would say the infection came back from the blood, and the patient should take another dose of anti-malarials, but of a different kind to that which they originally had, in order to kill all of the parasites.

Finally, there is what is called relapse, which only occurs with two types of malaria: Plasmodium vivax and Plasmodium ovale. These are able to form dormant stages in the liver, so even when all the parasites are killed in the blood by the malarial treatment, these dormant forms survive. Many weeks, months or even years later, these dormant liver stages can re-activate and enter the blood again, causing new malaria symptoms. In this case, the liver was the source of the parasites. Again, the active blood infection should be treated with anti-malarials, but the patient should also talk to their doctor about taking primaquine, a drug which can kill any remaining dormant liver forms and thus prevent future relapses.

Duration of Malaria Symptoms

by

QUESTION

If untreated how long will a person suffer symptoms caused by Malaria?

ANSWER

The answer to that depends a lot on what type of malaria they have as well as their own immune status, and particularly if they have been infected with malaria before. So, for example, P. falciparum is the most severe and deadly kind of malaria, and without treatment, many people who do not have acquired immunity (from previous infections) are likely to die within just a few days. This is the type of malaria that causes the most deaths, and explains why most of the fatalities occur in young children, who have not had the chance to acquire immunity.

In contrast, other kinds of malaria are less severe, and so symptoms can persist before the malaria parasite is naturally cleared by the parasite, usually within 1-2 weeks. In extreme cases, this can last much longer; Plasmodium malariae is the slowest replicating form of malaria, and so frequently causes mild infections which can last weeks, if not months. In some cases, people are infected with low levels of P. malariae for years without even experiencing symptoms, since their own immune system is able to keep levels of the parasite low enough so that they don’t cause noticeable disease.

Malaria and Nausea

by

QUESTION

Can malaria cause vomiting when a smell of petrol is inhaled?

ANSWER

One of the symptoms of malaria is nausea, and vomiting can also occur, but it would not necessarily be linked to certain smells. The most characteristic symptom malaria is a high fever, often also accompanied by periods of chills. See more malaria symptoms here.

Malaria Diagnosis

by

QUESTION

How to identify malaria? My son has fever and headache for the past three days and also vomiting. Is treatment is necessary and what type of treatment he needs?

ANSWER

You need to take your son to the doctor or to a clinic where they can do a blood test to look for malaria. They will either look at his blood under a microscope or use his blood in a “rapid diagnostic test” (RDT), both of which can identify the presence of the malaria parasites in his blood. If he is positively diagnosed with malaria, then your son should receive treatment, probably a type of artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) – common brands include Coartem, Lonart and Alu (though there are many others). These are what the World Health Organisation recommends as first line treatment against non-severe malaria.

Given your son’s symptoms, you should certainly go for a malaria test, just in case. However, vomiting is not usually a symptoms associated with malaria, so it is also possible he has another infection, such as an intestinal parasite, or even a bacterial or viral infection. Unfortunately, the symptoms of malaria are very general, so you really need to have one of the blood tests I mention above in order to be sure that your son has malaria.

Malaria Test – Can Malaria Return?

by

QUESTION

I am working in Tanzania. I felt sick about 10 days ago and I went for a test for malaria and the test was positive. The doctor gave me some pills and said I must come back in one week for a test again. I went back and it was negative but now I don’t feel too good. Is it possible for the malaria to come back after 10 days?

ANSWER

It is unlikely that the malaria has come back, and if your malaria test is negative, then you probably don’t have malaria any more, and you can be confident the treatment worked. It sometimes takes a few days or even a couple of weeks to fully recover from the infection, since it takes quite a toll on the body’s immune system. Also, the medication you take to treat malaria can also have side effects, such as nausea and headaches, which actually seem similar to the symptoms of malaria itself.

Death from Malaria: Humans and Other Primates

by

QUESTION

If not treated in some form, do most who acquire malaria die? What about primates, such as orangutans that live in the wild and would not be treated as such. Do they die or do they become chronically ill within period of remission?

ANSWER

That’s a really good question, and the answer is: it depends! In humans, the most deadly form of malaria is Plasmodium falciparum—when infected for the first time, if not given prompt treatment, many people will die from this infection. However, after repeated infections, people develop acquired immunity to the P. falciparum parasite which means they are increasingly able to survive subsequent infections without treatment. This reason of acquired immunity is why young children, who do not yet have immunity, and visitors to malarial areas tend to have the most severe infections and most require treatment in order to survive.

The other three major forms of human malaria, P. vivax, P. malariae and P. ovale, are generally less deadly, though they can also result in death in some circumstances if the person does not have immunity and is not treated. Although much less common than P. falciparum, P. knowlesi is the fifth type of malaria to infect humans (it is more commonly an infection of macaque monkeys in south-east Asia), and because it replicates in a 24-hour cycle (the other types of human malaria have either a 48 or 72 hour cycle), high parasite loads can establish very quickly, leading to severe disease. As such, P. knowlesi is also quite dangerous and a high proportion of untreated cases result in death.

It is great that you ask about malaria in other primate species—as with humans, some forms of malaria are tolerated reasonably well while others are more deadly. It varies depending on the type of malaria as well as the species of primate. So, for example, P. knowlesi in long-tailed macaques is rarely observed to cause severe disease. In fact, infected macaques sometimes don’t even appear to have any symptoms. In contrast, if rhesus macaques are experimentally infected with P. knowlesi (the transmission range of this type of malaria does not overlap with the natural range of rhesus macaques), almost 100% of them will die without treatment.

You ask specifically about orangutans: one problem is that it is unclear which, and how many, species of malaria infect these apes. Past research has uncovered two species which are thought to be unique to orangutans (namely P. silvaticum and P. pitheci) while molecular studies have also shown non-specific species, namely human P. vivax and macaque P. cynomolgi and P. inui. As such, while originally orangutan malaria was thought to be not very dangerous to these apes, more recently there have been reports of orangutans showing very human-like symptoms suggestive of more advanced disease. However, rarely do studies link symptoms and observations of parasites in the blood, so it is unclear which parasites are causing these symptoms, if indeed it is malaria at all (in some sanctuary/rehabilitation center settings, orangutans exhibiting malaria symptoms have responded positively to treatment with anti-malarials, though this is not definitive evidence that their symptoms were caused by malaria).

So, in short, more research should be done on wild primates, particularly using molecular tools, to ascertain accurately what species of malaria they are infected with, and whether they are associated with symptoms and/or severe disease.

Diagnostic Blood Test: Malaria in Nepal and India

by

QUESTION

My daughter has returned from a 6 week trip to Nepal and then India. About 20 minutes into the flight home she developed pains and aches in her hips and legs, fever, generally feeling dreadful but no nausea or diarrhea. When she arrived after the 10 hour flight her temperature was 100.5. We were concerned about malaria, but when she saw her primary care doctor the next morning she felt much better and her temperature was normal.

Blood taken at that visit showed no sign of malaria, but the doctor said that she could develop a recurrence in 3-4 weeks time when blood test should be repeated to confirm malaria if present.

I don’t doubt her doctor, but do these symptoms suggest malaria? How common is it for an initial episode of malaria to show up as negative on blood tests? She started taking tablets 3 days before entering a high risk area and took them for 3 weeks, but stopped during a brief diarrheal illness and did not restarted her anti malaria tablets.

ANSWER 1 – From Malaria.com Editor:

I think your GP might be mistaken about this – the only way to diagnose malaria is through a blood test which is positive for the disease! I have never heard of any cases where the initial blood test is negative, followed by a positive recurrence several weeks later. There are cases were the initial level of infection is quite low, in which case sometimes the parasites can be missed when looking at the blood film; however, when symptoms are present, this is rare. Moreover, there is no biological reason for a recurrence in several weeks; usually, reoccurrence occurs when treatment is given and for whatever reason is unsuccessful, allowing the malaria parasites to come back (and this assumes they are positively observed in the first place!).

Another diagnostic option, if you want to double check, is to see if you can find a rapid diagnostic test for malaria, which uses a drop of the patient’s blood to look for proteins produced by the malaria parasite. Similarly, there are tests which look for antibodies against malaria; this kind of test, known as serology, is not good for diagnosing active infections since antibodies can persist after the infection has been cleared, but may give you an indication of whether your daughter was exposed to malaria at all during her time in Nepal. Both of these are even more sensitive than blood smears, and although not as common as blood smears, are available in many places, particularly through hospitals which have tropical medicine departments or experts. All in all, if your GP is insisting on a second malaria test in a few weeks, by all means there is no harm in doing that, but in the meantime I would seek a second opinion since I think it is more likely your daughter has another infection (possibly a gastrointestinal bug, or a viral infection) which may risk going undiagnosed if your GP fixates on malaria as the answer.

Regarding the symptoms, unfortunately the symptoms of malaria are very general and it is almost impossible to accurately diagnose the disease on the basis of symptoms alone, hence why a blood test is so important. The blood test, with positive observation of the malaria parasites, is also crucial to determine which species of malaria the patient has, which may have implications for the appropriate treatment.

Answer 2: From Malaria.com Medical Advisor (MD)

The diagnosis of malaria should always be considered for patients with a fever who have traveled to malaria endemic areas. Your concerns that this may be malaria are well founded. Malaria symptoms in the first few days of infection are similar to the early stages of many other febrile illnesses, including viral and bacterial infections. In malaria, the fever also typically waxes and wanes in the manner you described. Confirming the diagnosis requires detecting parasites or their products in a blood sample. The most common test involves inspecting blood under a microscope for the presence of malaria parasites. Sometimes early in the disease there aren’t enough parasites for detection by this method. For this reason, several blood smears taken at 12-24 hour intervals are sometimes required to rule out a diagnosis of malaria in a symptomatic patient.

Additionally, your daughter was vulnerable to infection because she stopped taking antimalaria medicines while traveling in a region of malaria risk. To offer protection, these medicines must be taken for the duration of the stay, and depending on the medicine, up to 4 weeks after the last possible malaria exposure.

Unfortunately most medical doctors in regions where malaria is very rare, like the the United States and Europe, have little experience diagnosing and managing malaria. I would advise you to seek attention at a travel clinic or infectious disease specialist without delay, where it is likely further blood tests will be undertaken immediately to establish laboratory confirmation, and the prompt initiation of treatment for malaria if present.